Find the Right Fit for Small Business Retirement Plans in Canada

Last updated

EBsource is committed to providing reliable, well-researched information so Canadians can make informed decisions about employee benefits. Our content is prepared and edited under the EBsource editorial guidelines.

Small business retirement plans in Canada include several options: Group Registered Retirement Savings Plans, Registered Retirement Savings Plan/Deferred Profit Sharing Plan combinations, Pooled Registered Pension Plans, Defined Contribution Pension Plans, and Voluntary Retirement Savings Plans. Group Tax-Free Savings Accounts and Defined Benefit Plans can also be used as a workplace savings option.

When choosing a retirement plan for your Canadian small business, it starts with three questions: What can you afford to contribute, who needs to participate, and how much administration can you handle? This guide compares seven workplace retirement and savings options, walks through an $18,000 employer contribution example, and gives you six questions to ask before accepting a provider quote.

Which Retirement Plan Fits Your Small Business Budget and Admin Capacity?

Main retirement plan options available in Canada are a Group Registered Retirement Savings Plan (Group RRSPs), a Group Registered Retirement Savings Plan combined with a Deferred Profit Sharing Plan (RRSP/DPSP combinations), a Pooled Registered Pension Plan (PRPPs), a Defined Contribution Pension Plan (DC pension plan), and a Quebec Voluntary Retirement Savings Plan (Quebec VRSPs). A Defined Benefit Plan and a Group Tax-Free Savings Account (Group TFSA) may also be relevant in some situations.

For your small business retirement plan options, focus on two main questions: How much can you realistically contribute, and how much administrative effort can you manage? Before comparing structures, set clear goals for what the plan should do. Retention, tax-efficient compensation, and simply helping your employees save for retirement lead to different shortlists. Those goals, not headcount, are what turn a packaged product into a customized plan.

If you are not ready to make employer contributions, start by comparing structures that can operate without them, such as an employee-funded group Registered Retirement Savings Plan, a Pooled Registered Pension Plan or a Voluntary Retirement Savings Plan where applicable.

If you want to contribute but keep the amount flexible, consider a matching plan or a Deferred Profit Sharing Plan. On the other hand, a Defined Contribution Pension Plan creates a more formal employer contribution commitment because the contribution rate is set in the registered plan terms.

If you run an early-stage company whose headcount and funding may change within a year, our guide to retirement benefits for Canadian startups shows how to test a plan design against secured funding and your hiring plan before you commit.

The following table outlines four common starting points, what each option includes, and the constraints that might eliminate certain choices:

Your situationWhat to shortlistWhen it may not fit
Not ready to contribute yetGroup RRSP with payroll deduction only, or a PRPP or VRSPA stand-alone defined contribution money purchase provision generally requires an employer contribution of at least 1% of active members’ total pensionable earnings, subject to specific registered-plan exceptions.
Want to contribute but keep the commitment adjustableGroup RRSP match, or a DPSP drafted so the contribution can follow profitAvoid writing a rate into a pension plan text you would need a regulatory process to change.
Want employer contributions that are not included in employees’ current taxable income and generally do not attract CPP or EIDPSP, CRA-registered PRPP or VRSP, or DC pension planA group RRSP or TFSA match will show up in box 14 and code 40
No dedicated HR or payroll staffPRPP or VRSP, or a small-business product with payroll file integrationAny plan still leaves you deducting, remitting and enrolling on schedule
Employees in several provinces, or any in QuebecConfirm jurisdiction before shortlisting, and confirm whether your Quebec employees are already covered by a qualifying arrangementA federally registered PRPP can operate across the provinces participating in the current PRPP Agreement. QC employees under provincial jurisdiction are instead covered through the VRSP regime. AB, PEI and NL are not current parties to that multilateral agreement, so employers should confirm local availability and registration requirements with the administrator before assuming one PRPP can cover those employees.
Wants to participate alongside staffGroup RRSP, DC pension plan, PRPP depending on jurisdiction, VRSP in QuebecA DPSP cannot include a person related to the employer, or a person who is or is related to a specified shareholder of the employer or a related corporation. Additional rules apply to partnerships and trusts.
Want to offer employees flexible savings alongside retirement savingsGroup TFSA added to an RRSP or DPSP, an unrestricted group RRSP, or a VRSP for the employee-funded portionA PRPP locks in employee contributions under the federal regime. A group RRSP may restrict access to employer-funded amounts before retirement or termination, which can change the EI treatment of the employer contribution. That contractual restriction is not the same as pension-law locking-in.
How your contribution commitment and admin capacity narrow the shortlist

The payroll-tax difference becomes important once the employer starts contributing. Employer contributions to a group Registered Retirement Savings Plan are taxable benefits and are generally pensionable for CPP purposes. EI treatment depends on the plan’s withdrawal rules. If employees can withdraw the employer-funded amounts before retirement or termination, the contributions are generally insurable. If the group RRSP prevents those withdrawals, apart from permitted Home Buyers’ Plan or Lifelong Learning Plan withdrawals, the employer contribution is generally non-insurable for EI; CPP can still apply.

On the other hand, money put into a Deferred Profit Sharing Plan is not counted as income and does not require CPP contributions and EI premiums, so more of the budget goes straight into employee accounts. When considering withdrawal restrictions, assess the payroll implications alongside your plan’s savings objectives and the access employees will retain. Make those restrictions clear during enrolment.

Contribution commitment and administrative capacity lead to different retirement-plan shortlists and final suitability checks
Contribution commitment and administrative capacity

What Should You Compare in a Small Business Retirement Plan Quote?

We suggest small businesses send every provider the same business profile and the same questions, because quotes built on different assumptions cannot be compared, however clearly each one is written. 

Give each provider the same five inputs: the provinces your employees work in, eligible headcount, eligible payroll, your intended contribution rate and design, and your payroll platform. 

Then ask each of them the same six questions as below:

  • Participation: what take-up rate is this quote based on, and what changes if fewer employees join?
  • Eligibility: do we meet your minimum employees, contributions or assets; how is each minimum measured, and what happens to our pricing or eligibility in a year we fall below it?
  • Fee split: which fees do we pay, which come out of member accounts, and what does a member pay to withdraw, transfer or leave?
  • Plan design: can we restrict withdrawals of employer contributions, what does that do to our EI cost, and for a Deferred Profit Sharing Plan, what can we change in the contribution formula without a CRA amendment?
  • Payroll: is our platform integrated, or do we upload a file each cycle? Who is accountable for correcting contribution errors, and on what timeline?
  • Exit: what does it take to move providers or wind the arrangement down, and what does that cost our members and us?

When Is a Consultation With Outside Experts Worth It?

Once more than one jurisdiction, a connected person or a locked-in design is involved. Some products are sold only through a licensed advisor, so the conversation may not be optional. Give the experts you engage the same five inputs you gave every provider, and ask them to confirm the pension jurisdiction that applies to each employee group before you sign anything.

If your employees work in Ontario, see how to price a workplace retirement plan in Ontario, line by line, once you have a shortlist.

Quebec Employers: Check VRSP Obligations Before Comparing Plans

In Quebec, some employers are required to offer a Voluntary Retirement Savings Plan or another qualifying workplace savings or pension arrangement. Check that obligation before comparing voluntary plan designs. The Voluntary Retirement Savings Plans Act requires some employers to offer a plan, and the CNESST enforces the obligation rather than Retraite Québec.

First, an employer must offer a plan by 31 December 2026 if it had at least 5 eligible employees on 31 December 2025 and 10 or more on 30 June 2026. In addition, an eligible employee is at least 18, is an employee within the meaning of the Act respecting labour standards, and has one year of uninterrupted service. Part-time status alone does not exclude an employee. However, an employee who has not yet completed one year of uninterrupted service does not yet meet the Voluntary Retirement Savings Plan eligibility test.

If the employer has fewer than 10 eligible employees on June 30, the December 31 obligation is not triggered for that year under the current threshold. Recheck the employee count and current CNESST rules each year.

So, start by confirming whether an existing qualifying arrangement already covers your eligible employees. That answer may eliminate some options before you begin comparing voluntary plan designs.

Source: 2026 Benefit Amounts and Key Data – Retraite Québec

Do Canadian Employers Have to Offer Retirement Plans?

Outside Quebec, there is no general legal requirement for private-sector employers to offer a workplace retirement plan such as a group RRSP, DPSP or pension plan. Employers must deduct and remit CPP or QPP and EI where the employment and employee are subject to those programs. Specific exemptions and non-insurable-employment rules can apply.

Can New Canadians Join A Workplace Retirement Plan?

Citizenship alone does not generally determine whether a new Canadian can participate in a workplace retirement arrangement, but the tax and contribution rules depend on the plan. Registered Pension Plan eligibility follows the plan terms and applicable pension legislation.

Check Group RRSP and PRPP contributions against the individual’s available RRSP deduction limit; a newcomer generally cannot deduct first-year RRSP contributions if it is their first Canadian return and they have no previously established room. For a group TFSA, the individual must meet the TFSA residency, age and SIN requirements, and contribution room begins in the year Canadian residency starts. Québec VRSP employees must also meet the applicable employment and service requirements.

Does Business Size Rule Out Any of These Retirement Plans?

Headcount alone does not create a single Canada-wide minimum that determines which of these arrangements a small employer can use. However, pension legislation, jurisdiction, plan terms and provider eligibility rules can still affect availability.

What Happens to the Group Retirement Plan When the Business Is Sold?

It depends on how the sale is structured. The plan may end, transfer to the buyer, or continue with the buyer as the new employer, so address it during the sale rather than after.

Ending a plan involves formal steps. To close a DPSP, the employer or trustee must send the CRA a letter or board decision showing when and how plan assets will be paid to beneficiaries. Winding up a DC pension plan must follow the pension rules for each employee group, including notifying members and filing with regulators. Where several employers share a plan and only one leaves, the plan can stay registered for the others.

Confirm the details with the CRA and the relevant pension regulator before finalizing the purchase agreement.

Where Are the Official Lists of PRPP and VRSP Administrators?

Regulators publish these lists directly. OSFI’s list of registered PRPPs names five federal plans, administered by The Royal Trust Company, Industrielle Alliance, The Canada Life Assurance Company, The Manufacturers Life Insurance Company and Sun Life Assurance Company of Canada. The page was last modified on 1 March 2023, so confirm the current roster with OSFI before relying on it.

For Quebec, Retraite Québec’s list of registered VRSPs also shows each plan’s investment options and fees.

Note that the OSFI list covers only federal PRPPs. A provider’s absence from it says nothing about its group RRSP or DPSP products.

Which Options Can Reduce the Small Business Retirement Plan Setup Work?

Two are worth asking every provider about. A financial institution can have a Deferred Profit Sharing Plan specimen plan approved by the CRA in advance, and an employer adopting that specimen does not file its own plan text or trust agreement with the application. 

In Quebec, a Simplified Pension Plan (SIPP) is another small-business option in which an authorized financial institution handles much of the plan administration. It should not be presented as a Canada-wide equivalent.

Aaron Cyr
Aaron Cyr
Aaron Cyr is the Website Content Writer at Ebsource.com, where he focuses on creating clear, accessible content about Canadian government benefits and public assistance programs. With thorough research and a close eye on policy changes, he provides reliable, up-to-date information on the government benefits that matter most to Canadian workers.